Yes, I agree--GDP is not the best climate metric of our well-being as a country.
Here's an interesting chart showing "World Happiness" on a variety of measures. US winds up being #18 overall; however, you can actually choose which variable you want to rank order the countries by. Doing that, I found that the "Land of the Free" actually are 51st in "Freedom to Make Life Choices." We're 33 in "Healthy Life Expectancy." We're 36 in "Social Support." But we are 10th in GDP.
"Do any human beings ever realize life while they live it--every, every minute?" Emily Webb, Our Town
www.silententry.wordpress.com
Asking the measure of a country’s greatness is problematic in my mind. If one claims superior happiness, the other might say they’re simply afraid to complain. Is it the generosity of its welfare state? Military, economic or scientific prowess? Equality of condition or of opportunity? Internal comity or tolerance? Freedom to compete to speak or act? Long term survival?
Is there any dispositive proof of one society’s superiority to another?
The happiness stuff does seem too difficult to remove from bias as some might just be social attitudes to more or less expression of positive/negative feelings,and that can be independent of how much such feelings are actually experienced.
However some things are just bad period or at the very least are bad within the context of that social system (and that's kinda key because it all is experienced in a social system). A country where half the population is near starvation, ok that's just bad period, in any system. Extreme poverty amongst extreme wealth tends to be that kind of bad. Poverty by itself, uh at the point of starvation etc. yes, but not at that point in a country where pretty much everyone is poor ... maybe... it depends.
Trees don't grow on money
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)