We went through that exercise, too! We also have a smaller kitchen and most newer faucets are proportioned for huge kitchens. But I found most of the smaller ones to lack style.
I'm happy with what we settled on. This one is the closest I can find to ours. The arc is a little more stylish, and the spray hose eliminates the need for the pull-out. It is perfectly proportioned for my kitchen.
https://www.lowes.com/pd/Moen-Muirfi...Faucet/3595906