Like everyone else around us, a summer hailstorm devastated our roof and it will need to be replaced. The neighbor behind us recently opened his own roofing business and came to our door asking for his business. If one operates on gut feelings about decisions as I sometimes do, I would rather not use his services. He has done a few in the neighborhood and did not pull permits for any of them, etc. I am however concerned about alienating a neighbor since he has extended neighborly kindnesses in the past and I know he will take it personally. He would probably also give us a better price. Thoughts?