Actually, I am picky, but DH isn't as much so. I mostly buy for him. He has to think so hard during the work week, I think he likes to be mindless for awhile on the weekends! There's many I don't watch with him.
I haven't decided about keeping Biutiful. I haven't opened it yet. It sounds really depressing. I used to like depressing, if it was a very good movie, but not so much so any more. I'll let you know if I watch it.
We can't "stream" any movies where we are. We only have a limited amount of internet time, and I usually don't want to "waste" it on a movie.
The library in our little town doesn't have much to offer, and the Blockbuster store closed several years ago.
We might try Netflix. We do have alot of old DVDs, but we have watched them all many times over.
Plus, we never go to the movies (or anywhere for that matter), so I don't mind spending a little on DVDs. The actual packaging does bother me, but at least there's a recycling place about 40 miles from here that accepts CD and their cases, etc.