PDA

View Full Version : DHL, passive resistance and failing leadership.



SOS
12-30-14, 4:24am
Hi,

while I was driving to work this morning, I was pondering a small meeting I had yesterday with a sales rep from DHL.

Basically what happened was that I have switched from using UPS to DHL about a year ago, and now we don't seem to be making the volume with DHL so they are moving us to another discount category. In other words, we are going to pay more for our shipments. I suspect it will be nickles and dimes and it is basically a non-issue, but it made me think about the whole thing.

The old situation was that someone made a deal with UPS back in the mists of time and we had no contact with them, except the invoices and the couriers. So when DHL came along, I checked the rates and on the longer distances we made considerable savings, sometimes up to 60-70%. So, like a good little office-soldier, I made up the Excel sheets, made the comparisons, and presented my case to management.
Their response was very much like a scene from The Godfather, where the undertaker asks the Don for a favour.

The response from the people in my office was another thing. Some responded with blank stares, even though the costs were going down considerably. Others were more positive, and others adopted a stance of passive resistance. I call that active passiveness, as they sure put a whole lot of effort into being passive.
So, during some meetings, the management here would mutter something about using DHL, but basically nothing changed. This ran alongside other processes in our office, like upgrading our ERP-system where the same attitudes prevailed.

So now, for me at least, the DHL-drama is representative of the way our company, and perhaps most organisations, function.

Lessons learned for me: never underestimate mean little office dwellers who look innocent, being right never gives you instant results, Lone Rangers do not always get the girl at the end and instead of asking what I can do for the Company, I should ask what I can learn from the Company.

And all that at the end of the year.

Lainey
12-30-14, 2:43pm
In my many years of working in offices I've found that inertia is the biggest obstacle to change. So I wouldn't ascribe much evil intent in your scenario, but rather a normal human resistance to doing things differently than the way they've always been done.
The best, and most times only, way to get the change instituted is for senior leadership to mandate it. If they won't, then they deserve to pay the higher costs. But good for you for investigating and demonstrating the difference. If I were you, I'd keep that as an example for when I interview for my next job - it would be very positive for your interviewers to see an example of your initiative.

SteveinMN
12-30-14, 6:50pm
Lessons learned for me: never underestimate mean little office dwellers who look innocent, being right never gives you instant results
"Mean little office dwellers" are the people who make or break a company/organization. When you fly, the airline is not the CEO or the marketing analyst who figured the seat mix; it's the brusque flight attendant and the imperious gate clerk. And until those folks buy into the paradigm, nothing will change. I would look for the intangible reasons UPS was selected in the first place. It might have had little or nothing to do with money.

SOS
12-31-14, 4:13am
You are both very right. I have been working here for 5 years now, and it has made me grow up very quickly in regards to business and management, I think.

And Steve, I suspect the only reason why UPS was selected back in the days was that they gave reasonable rates, but nobody ever checked to see if they are still reasonable.

Inertia, that is indeed the right word here.

Anyway, best wishes everyone!

Packy
1-3-15, 2:38am
Typical initiative-killing, in some places. It is a top-down syndrome, and one factor in burnout. The Management causes it. But, it's their problem. Here's how to cope: Don't stick your neck out, don't try and save the company money, because no good deed goes unpunished. Someone higher-up will take credit, if your idea is implemented successfully. Use the expedient to complete your assigned tasks, nothing more. Let the numbers crunchers crunch the numbers. The only initiative you should show is to arrive at work 1/2 hour early & drink coffee & hold the door open for the bosses, office staff, etc. But, be darn sure to get out the door on time, at the end of the day. Keep your head down, nose to the grindstone. Keep your work area extremely neat. Don't let them see you talking at the water cooler or out of your area. Always have a pleasant and cheerful demeanor. Never show impatience or irritation or anger, with anyone. No matter how much they deserve it. Listen to gossip and rumors without being seen, but never repeat it. It is an essential survival tactic, because scuttlebutt is usually true, to some degree. Have I left anything out? Probably. But, that's basically the rules to live by, until you find something better. Most, but not all, people with initiative and creativity will move on---or turn to substance abuse or religion.. Other people are born to sit in the galley and row the boat. You must decide which category you fit. See? Hope that helps you some.

shadowmoss
1-3-15, 5:43am
Wow. I actually agree with Packy. I gotta go think about that.

jp1
1-3-15, 9:56am
Yeah, I think packy nailed it. Right up to the substance abuse or religion comment. I worked with someone who started with the former but then switched to the latter. She was just as crazy and bitter with the latter, but at least she wasn't puking in the restroom on a regular basis anymore.