Log in

View Full Version : Getting off the Christmas gift treadmill question



jp1
12-16-15, 11:49pm
Over time I've managed to reduce the number of people I feel obligated to give Christmas gifts to. Some just fell away when one or the other didn't send a gift one year. Some died. A couple I actually had conversations with where we agreed to stop sending gifts. This year I was down to two people to shop for. One is SO. I haven't bought him anything major, but I've bought a number of small things that he will enjoy because they involve me knowing him well enough to show that I actually pay attention to him and his interests. I will always buy gifts for him because I enjoy doing so.

The other is a friend who has no remaining family and I'm her best friend. We've been very close for 25 years. I've always just assumed that I'd always need to send her gifts since no one else likely will. A couple of days ago she surprised me with an email suggesting that since neither of us needs or is particularly wanting anything (we both make enough money at this point in our lives to pretty much buy anything we really want) that we not exchange gifts. I wrote back and suggested we each give to a charity that is important to the other, to which she agreed and sent info about a charity that she had already donated to a couple of weeks ago. Not surprisingly given my friend's personal circumstances it's an organization whose clients are teenage foster kids and as such who won't likely be getting gifts from anyone, so they are asking for gifts for their clients. I think it's awesome that she is aware that there are people whose lives are similar to hers and wants to do what she can to help them have a better Christmas and have happily sent some gifts for teenage boy clients of the organization (according to the organization the least likely to receive anything for the holidays).

Now to my question. Prior to our email conversation I had already planned to send her a few pints of Graeter's Ice Cream for Christmas. It's super delicious and she loves it. (and it's not going to cause more clutter in her apartment.) Plus she sent some of this ice cream to SO a couple of months back as an "I'm thinking of you pick me up" because he's been going through some significant ongoing health issues and was feeling down. My question, do I still send her some ice cream even though we've now agreed not to exchange gifts? Or perhaps dial it back to just a couple of pints as an acknowledgement of our friendship (instead of the six pints I'd planned on)? Or what? I think she'd really enjoy the ice cream, but I don't want to be the jerk who ignored our agreed upon plan.

Valley
12-17-15, 12:35am
Stay with your plan...don't be the one who ignores the agreed upon plan. Send her some ice cream for Valentine's Day.

ApatheticNoMore
12-17-15, 1:14am
Yea send the ice cream at another time of the year, not as exchanging gifts but as just a gift apropos of nothing (now of course summer would be ideal but that is a long ways off, so whenever).

kally
12-17-15, 2:41am
well done. We have been off this train for over 5 years. We give 2 gifts to young uns. And just one small gift between SO and I. So easy, so within our budget.

iris lilies
12-17-15, 10:58am
I am obligated for only two people, and one of them, DH, has very modest needs and wants. Just some small thing or two for him suffices.If
I am out of ideas a bar of Lindt chocolate is the deal.

If I buy for others it is not from obligation and I don't mind it. This year
I bought for 3 extra people and that's ok. Although I will say that an obligations seems to be creeping up for another couple who we have spent the last few Christmas Eve's with, so ugh.

Alan
12-17-15, 11:18am
Now to my question. Prior to our email conversation I had already planned to send her a few pints of Graeter's Ice Cream for Christmas. It's super delicious and she loves it. (and it's not going to cause more clutter in her apartment.) Plus she sent some of this ice cream to SO a couple of months back as an "I'm thinking of you pick me up" because he's been going through some significant ongoing health issues and was feeling down. My question, do I still send her some ice cream even though we've now agreed not to exchange gifts? Or perhaps dial it back to just a couple of pints as an acknowledgement of our friendship (instead of the six pints I'd planned on)? Or what? I think she'd really enjoy the ice cream, but I don't want to be the jerk who ignored our agreed upon plan.
Being a regional brand, many people may not know that Graeter's is the second best ice cream in the entire world! I'd send it as a commemoration of your friendship rather than as a gift.

Chicken lady
12-17-15, 11:28am
Second best?

jp1
12-17-15, 11:42am
Second best?

I agree. Second best? I'm curious what #1 is. Perhaps I need to be sending that instead...

SteveinMN
12-17-15, 11:58am
I would send it anyway. The time is immaterial.

Just last week I gave a work-related gag gift to each of couple of former co-workers with whom I occasionally have lunch. I did preface the giving by referring to the time of year and that it was not a Christmas gift but something inexpensive I saw that I thought they'd appreciate (they did).

None of us are guaranteed a tomorrow. If you appreciate this person's presence in your life, there is no time like the present to say 'thank you'. Clarify the giving circumstances if you want, but I would go ahead with the gift.

Alan
12-17-15, 11:59am
Second best?Another regional brand, founded just down the street from Graeter's, United Dairy Farmers 'Homemade' brand. Of course, that's a source of much debate locally, but I think I'm on the right side of that issue. ;)

iris lilies
12-17-15, 12:46pm
Agree with valley. Don't confuse your friend, mean what you say. People and usually women have a hellova a time breaking with a feeling of obligation for gifting.

OP understand that you have already given her a gift by removing that obligation.

jp1
12-17-15, 1:37pm
Thank you all for your thoughts. It's funny that I'm the one having trouble with letting go of the obligation. But I will. I think I'll send the ice cream in mid-January. Perhaps they have 'I have a dream' flavor...

Chicken lady
12-17-15, 7:00pm
Alan, Nope. No you're not.:-D

Alan
12-17-15, 8:34pm
Alan, Nope. No you're not.:-D
Ha, you sound like my wife.