Magnolia tree trimming

[jp1]

Our next door neighbor has a big magnolia tree in his backyard. The leaves and seedpods falling in our yard are constant work but the shade it provides in the summer is great. He needed to trim it back as it was getting too close to our house which is a wildfire hazard. (we live in a townhouse so our homes are attached). Since he's retired he has been doing it himself, slowly over the past month. At this point there is little tree left. I'm bummed that we won't have much shade this summer but it's his tree so I suppose he can do with it as he pleases. And he was polite enough to let us know that he'd be doing this and has been cleaning up the mess made in our yard due to the part that crossed over the fence. Is this how one should trim a magnolia?

Here are the before/after pics (helpfully turned sideways by the forum software so that everyone can stretch the muscles on the right side of their neck...)

4162
4163

[razz]

Having a little difficulty seeing this as the pictures appear to be from different viewpoints. Is tree remaining after the pruning just the blunt arms with all the smaller branches and leaf buds cut away?
It may take some time to recover with sprouts of new branches next spring. Usually a pruning thins only about a third of leaf area in order for the tree to to feed itself.

[catherine]

Yes, it looks like your neighbor went to town on that tree. Magnolias are beautiful--I hope it comes back.

[rosarugosa]

AS far as I can see, that isn't the way one would prune anything unless the ultimate goal is to take it down completely.

[jp1]

Having a little difficulty seeing this as the pictures appear to be from different viewpoints. Is tree remaining after the pruning just the blunt arms with all the smaller branches and leaf buds cut away?
It may take some time to recover with sprouts of new branches next spring. Usually a pruning thins only about a third of leaf area in order for the tree to to feed itself.

Sorry. They are from different perspectives. The ‘now’ picture was taken from in our yard.

[jp1]

AS far as I can see, that isn't the way one would prune anything unless the ultimate goal is to take it down completely.

Our other next door neighbor prunes her rose bushes this way which seems to be the right thing to do but flowers are different from trees.

[catherine]

Yes, cutting back perennial flowers is way different than pruning a tree.



Magnolia Tree Pruning Although pruning magnolia trees is not necessary, young trees can be shaped as they grow. Trimming a magnolia tree when it is young will also improve the health of the tree and encourage more blooms. Mature magnolia trees do not recover from pruning and can sustain fatal wounds. Therefore, magnolia tree pruning on older specimens should only be done as a last resort when necessary.
Read more at Gardening Know How: Magnolia Tree Pruning: Learn How And When To Prune Magnolia Trees https://www.gardeningknowhow.com/ornamental/trees/magnolia/pruning-magnolia-trees.htm

[jp1]

Ugggh. Thanks for the link. I guess now we need to start thinking about what we want to do for shade next summer.

[mschrisgo2]

Yes, that tree is a goner. Too bad, they can be so pretty!
Maybe look for some sort of moveable shade structure?

[jp1]

It’s been about a month now and there are seven new shoots growing from hacked off branches, each with seven or eight leaves. Hopefully it will grow more shoots as spring progresses. Otherwise it has a long way to go before it is back to its former glory. But I suspect my neighbor will never have to trim again. (He’s in his early 70’s)

[Tybee]

Downside when they do that to crepe myrtles they call it myrtlecide.

[razz]

I hope that the shoots make it. I have seen situations where the new shoots have sprouted and then dried up, becoming overwhelmed and diee

[jp1]

Well, apparently our neighbor is either lucky or actually knew what he was doing. At this point, now that spring is here, there are shoots in various stage of growth on virtually every branch of the tree. If this keeps up it will be starting to look like a normal tree again by this fall.

[razz]

Keeping my fingers crossed that the shoots survive.

[jp1]

Update. This tree is going to be fine. I don't know if our neighbor was lucky or knew what he was doing. But it's grown so many new branches/leaves that it already looks normal and by the end of summer will look like a neatly trimmed version of its previous self.

Sorry that the pic is turned. In the turkey thread I encouraged everyone to stretch the right muscles in their neck. Now you can stretch the left ones...
4597

[catherine]

Update. This tree is going to be fine. I don't know if our neighbor was lucky or knew what he was doing. But it's grown so many new branches/leaves that it already looks normal and by the end of summer will look like a neatly trimmed version of its previous self.

Sorry that the pic is turned. In the turkey thread I encouraged everyone to stretch the right muscles in their neck. Now you can stretch the left ones...
4597

Glad to hear. Flies in the face of what I've learned about pruning, but I'm no expert, and in fact, I'm typically a reluctant and cautious pruner. I'm always afraid of doing too much. I have a gardener friend who is says she has planted normal trees and made dwarf trees out of them. So maybe your neighbor goes by my friend's playbook.