Composting people

[jp1]

Apparently California recently put a law in place allowing people to be composted upon death starting in 2027. The process only takes a month and people are kept separate. The process doesn’t cause greenhouse gas emissions as cremation does so it would be the final environmentally friendly choice a person can make. Literally.

As an athiest I don’t have a problem with this. It seems incredibly practical. And I can even see a family taking the result and using it to plant a tree by which they could remember their loved one. But I’m curious what others thoughts are.

[nswef]

It seems as sensible as cremation.

[catherine]

Hmm... Seems VT is looking towards that as well. Not sure where this bill stands. This article is from last January.

https://vtdigger.org/2022/01/31/bill-would-allow-composting-of-human-remains/

I have looked into "natural burial" up here, and there is a cemetery near my house that is one of the few in the State that allows it.

https://naturalburialassociation.ca/about-natural-burial/

[bae]

How do they do this and not produce "greenhouse gas"?

[iris lilies]

How do they do this and not produce "greenhouse gas"?
I am curious too. I wouldn’t think that meat flesh disintegrates within one month regardless of how much brown stuff and green stuff you pile over it.

[Alan]

I am curious too. I wouldn’t think that meat flesh disintegrates within one month regardless of how much brown stuff and green stuff you pile over it.
I read about this a year or so ago, as I recall the body is placed in a metal cylinder along with wood chips and straw and the cylinder is then sealed. As all the organic material begins to decompose the inside reaches high temperatures and the cylinder is rotated on some set schedule to ensure even decomposition, and oxygen is added periodically. This process apparently will also decompose teeth and bones within a short period of time and you end up with about a cubic yard of rich, brown soil. I think there's a drying process which takes another couple of weeks.

[jp1]

How do they do this and not produce "greenhouse gas"?

All the articles I've found are vague on how much greenhouse gases are released through composting a human body but they all state that it's significantly less than the amount from cremation since fossil fuels are not burned in the process. I assume that the greenhouse gases from the body itself are roughly the same with either process?

[catherine]

As much as I like the idea of this in principle, I'm not sure. "Taking the result and planting a tree"--I simply can't visualize my kids taking a pitchfork to my "compost" I'm a little out there on this stuff, but not THAT out there. I think that's what appeals to me about natural burial. It's a more natural HUMAN option. I can see being wrapped in a shroud and then being put in the earth and the kids can then put a planting on the site. But USING my actual composted remains to fertilize a tree...IDK about that. Although knowing my kids, they would get plenty of good jokes out the experience.

ETA: Another "natural" option. Throw me in the woods and let the animals have at me. JK.

[jp1]

For sure every family would have their own opinion about using grandma to plant a tree. I imagine lots of families would prefer that the compost to go to a farm (here that mostly means vineyards). Perhaps people would be more comfortable serving a bottle of wine at thanksgiving while saying ‘it’s so nice that we can drink this wine made from grandma. It’s like communion but a little bit different!’

[pinkytoe]

I have never been drawn to the idea of cremation nor traditional casket burial. There is a funeral home near our house and seeing thick black smoke on occasion coming from their stacks is creepy. A shroud and burial is fine with me as all that matter will eventually disintegrate. Pretty sure that composting bodies is already being practiced in Colorado.

[iris lilies]

As much as I like the idea of this in principle, I'm not sure. "Taking the result and planting a tree"--I simply can't visualize my kids taking a pitchfork to my "compost" I'm a little out there on this stuff, but not THAT out there. I think that's what appeals to me about natural burial. It's a more natural HUMAN option. I can see being wrapped in a shroud and then being put in the earth and the kids can then put a planting on the site. But USING my actual composted remains to fertilize a tree...IDK about that. Although knowing my kids, they would get plenty of good jokes out the experience.

ETA: Another "natural" option. Throw me in the woods and let the animals have at me. JK.

For me, that would be fine. Only not for a tree. Lilies or hydrangeas or peonies, something nice that blooms.

[frugal-one]

My FIL used to say he didn't care what you did with him when he was dead.... He once said; "I don't care if you freeze my ass and pound me in the ground as a fencepost." I don't care what happens to me either...

[KayLR]

It's here in WA Bae.
https://www.seattlemet.com/health-and-wellness/2019/02/human-composting-offers-a-green-new-way-to-die
https://earthfuneral.com/service-area/
https://www.naturalburialground.org/

[littlebittybobby]

Well, I sat-n-watched that mooo-veee with Charleton Heston & he didn't say much about guns, BUT I think they had a revolutionary idea. See---they could use human bodies to prepare yummy meals! After all, you are what you eat, so why not eat humans? Then, you and your lovely wife could drive-n-eat to a restaurant you heard about, and EAT. Yup. Saves using land that could be under cultivation for corn-n-beans! Yup. I was sitting & watching episode 2, season 7 of Kitchen Nightmares, and the featured rest-o-rant was a pizza place in Doo-Doo Town, where the owner claimed his pizza was THE best, but no it was really bad, and he was very hard-headed and headed toward losing his business. They showed photos of his really bad pizza. Ha. I'll have to see the rest of the episode, so I can see if he changed his methods o' making pizza. But yeah---maybe they could use dead people as a topping on Pizza, but I really don't think I'd be inclined to order one. Nope. Hope that helps you kids some.4848